Stock Forum

Discuss value investing stock ideas

You must be logged in to post
Search Forums:


 






Wildcard Usage:
*    matches any number of characters
%    matches exactly one character

Book Review: Rich Dad Poor Dad by Robert T. Kiyosaki

No Tags
UserPost

3:11 pm
October 11, 2010


infinitee00

Member

posts 30

6

I don't know why I am posting this, but Robert Kiyosaki is not the most upright of people selling inspirational books. I would even call him a charlatan. The only reason he sold as many books as he did is because he could use the MLM groups like Quixtar etc to his advantage.

 

I remember once reading a yahoo colum in which he argued that making 30% annual returns in the stock market is easy. I facepalmed and stopped reading his articles. He is as clueless about the stock markets as anyone can be.

 

Reed's website is a great expose of Kiyosaki.

5:13 pm
May 10, 2010


Peridotic

Member

posts 10

5

Hey I remember reading this, I definitely found this book to mainly be motivation to save and invest and to think businesslike but the authors strategies are kind of fishy. Your conclusion says it the best. I even read this book before I got into value investing. So the book did help me achieve to be frugal and save. I think better books to read about similiar subject matters is The Millionaire Next Door and Why Smart People make money mistakes. Very interesting reads and will make you better overall. Check those out tell us what you think.

10:38 pm
April 26, 2010


Zefiro50

Washington

Member

posts 12

4

Post edited 5:48 am – April 27, 2010 by Zefiro50


Hi,

Thank you for this 2nd opinion. I guess I was brainwashed on the part that we're not going anywhere working for someone else and that we should be the Employer and not the employee. I agree with that. I didn't succumb myself to the other parts of the book like his investment strategy.

If what he saids is true about the beginnings of taxation I see a point why I should be a republican.

Thanks for showing this.

I would say the best way to take advantage of value investing is to read up to lesson 3 which is his motivational childhood, the history of taxes, learning Financial Literacy, and return the book to Half price book where you got it. I got this book for like 5 bucks and returning will get me back at least $3 dollars. And then apply that with Value investing.

Update: Or maybe just the financial literacy and the taxes portion and then get your refund.

10:28 am
April 26, 2010


Jae Jun

Admin

posts 1336

3

Post edited 5:40 am – April 27, 2010 by Jae Jun


Thanks for the review.

It's good to hear that you are thinking differently.

Regarding the 2 points of saving money.

I never like it when people mention loopholes, especially when it comes to taxes. It's just another way of telling you to be one step ahead of the government because loopholes are holes, which will be filled.

I don't like paying taxes, but I don't believe in trying to find ways around it. Take the tax breaks when you can, but doing it legit is always better. The IRS will catch up with you sooner or later.

The corporation is also a bad idea if you have no business, even more so if it's just to evade taxes. A mini version of Enron isn't what you want.

I haven't read the bookmyself, but one of the reasons is that I'm not fond of the author. Anyone who hangs out with Trump and considers himself to be a financial guru, I don't trust. They  make money selling their books, not in helping you gain wealth.

A great motivating book but it should be the start to further reading, studying and ideas.

9:41 am
April 26, 2010


Vince P

Member

posts 19

2

Just to play devil's advocate, look at this section of John T. Reed's website which seems devoted to being anti-Kiyosaki:

http://www.johntreed.com/Kiyosaki.html

I've never read the book, but wouldn't mind it if I had the time, mostly out of curiosity from all the discussion from both sides on it.

8:30 pm
April 25, 2010


Zefiro50

Washington

Member

posts 12

1

Hello all,

I would like to share a review on this for you all. I must say the author got my attention on life and I managed to finish this book in less than 3 days. It really was an eye opener on why we must break out of this "Rat Race" of a life and start building our own financial intelligience.

Overview:

The author basically had the experience of learning from two fathers. His biological father who a renown school teacher who was able to obtain Phd's through scholarships but subsequently died poor. His other father (who was his best friends father) only went to the 8th grade and dropped out but made millions of dollars.

For most people including myself, I was always told that by going to school and getting excellent grades would allow me to land a nice paying job that will financially secure me for the rest of my life. The way schools are taught is that "We work for money". Learn the skills you need to get the job you want. (Devry University's advertising motto)

On the other hand, the author explains that Rich people have "Money work for them" and that by following the lesson above most people either Middle Class or Poor will in the end be poor.

Here are the reason's why he states: You work to make the rich richer, you are taxed heavily by the government, Fear of losing money, and because you are financially illiterate. (There are more in the book)

Most people such as I believe that our home is our greatest asset but as this book points out, it is our biggest liability because we have a mortgage, pay property tax and pay for other things necessary for our homes to be comfortable. In order for property to be our greatest asset, it must produce income. It's value may go up over time but if you manage your money wisely, you could invest in other opportunities with the money that was placed into the mortgage to make more money faster instead of paying someone else for the loan and the interest.

Good Points:

I recommends this book on the following ideas. It makes you realize why you need to become financially literate because working for someone else for that paycheck means you're stuck in that "rat race" everybody is in. To become financially stable is to be able to produce income which doesn't come from someone else but from your own personal asset.

There are many loopholes and techniques to save money from what the author is saying.

1. Start a Corporation. That way you shield yourself from lawsuits and huge taxation. (I'm currently looking into this…)

2. 1031 Exhange Form. He seem to have made alot of money by flipping homes and using this IRS form to defer capital gain taxes. He then uses this to purchase bigger property and trading them. (Definitely looking into this one…)

Points I deviate from:

When it comes to value investing, I wouldn't get my ideas from this author because he doesn't really tell you how to invest the way we do. His small stock investment sounds very speculative for instance, he purchase an oil company at 68 cents and sold it in a couple years at 3 dollars because of what he heard from his speculator of a friend. He also is a flipper in property and you know what that caused back in 2007. But the basic idea he points out is that when you have money, you have it work for you and when your financially literate your able to utilize more of the accounting practice that saves you money the middle class and the poor class don't know about.

Conclusion:

This is how I would use this book. He's a great motivator and made me open my eyes on how life is. This book will definitely motivate you on how to come up with new ideas on making money and not by the outdated "Study hard in school and find a nice decent job that will pay for life". You will not find anything useful here when it comes to value investing but You'll start to appreciate what value investing is all about. You can find value in many things if you can buy it cheap and sell it high.

I like your feedbacks. Thanks.

No Tags


About the Stock Valuation Software forum

Most Users Ever Online: 147

Currently Online:
20 Guests

Currently Browsing this Topic:
1 Guest

Forum Stats:

Groups: 4
Forums: 40
Topics: 695
Posts: 3686

Membership:

There are 869 Members
There have been 8 Guests

There is 1 Admin
There are 3 Moderators

Top Posters:

somrh – 275
Graeme – 126
zehua – 96
valueinvestortoday – 75
nell – 67
krackerjack121 – 67

Recent New Members: cryspinn, kalidas, NathanB21, jademan10, romans122, vincentbston

Administrators: Jae Jun (1336 Posts)

Moderators: Jae Jun (1336 Posts), VANYA (1 Post), djsun (0 Posts)