Stock Forum

Discuss value investing stock ideas

 You must be logged in to post
Search Forums:


 






Wildcard Usage:
*    matches any number of characters
%    matches exactly one character

Home Questions your Links Tab

your Links Tab
Page:   1  
No Tags
UserPost

8:07 am
August 31, 2010


Jae Jun

Admin

posts 1336
2

If you do a search on his site, you will likely find an explanation. I doubt he will write an explanation of his method for every single post.

1. Some ratios are but modified.

3. I have many checklists to include in the spreadsheet by different gurus and standards so it's already under consideration.

4. Shadow stock is a great source of ideas for small caps. Just because a site doesnt give an analysis it shouldnt be disqualified as a bad site. You should ask the author directly about his methodolgy.

12:56 am
August 30, 2010


MrBook

Member

posts 30
1

Jae; In the links section I noticed that you listed Financial Gauges. I like the general idea of doing various ratio analysis. However I don't like the fact that the author (Neil Carven) does not do a good job explaining the reliability of the various ratios and how effective they have been over time. He also does not demonstrate what a good "Financial Gauge" score is. Here are some suggestions:

 

1. Perhaps these ratios could be included into the premium spreadsheet.

 

2. You could back test the various ratios to demonstrate what ratios have been effective and what have not been effective.

 

3. It appears that his scoring system is a more comprehensive version of what Piotroski did. Perhaps you could determine what a good "Financial Gauge" score.

 

Otherwise I don't understand why you even bothered to list this site since its not very transparent in its methods or recommendations.

 

4. The other question is why did you list Shadow Stock? That site gives a particular stock of the day but no analysis is given. What is this author's methodology anyway? Why do you like this site?

 

OK. Thanks.
No Tags
Page:   1  


About the Stock Valuation Software forum

Most Users Ever Online: 147

Currently Online:
14 Guests

Currently Browsing this Topic:
1 Guest

Forum Stats:

Groups: 4
Forums: 40
Topics: 694
Posts: 3680

Membership:

There are 868 Members
There have been 8 Guests

There is 1 Admin
There are 3 Moderators

Top Posters:

somrh – 273
Graeme – 122
zehua – 96
valueinvestortoday – 75
nell – 67
krackerjack121 – 67

Recent New Members: kalidas, NathanB21, jademan10, romans122, vincentbston, mrpenguin

Administrators: Jae Jun (1336 Posts)

Moderators: Jae Jun (1336 Posts), VANYA (1 Post), djsun (0 Posts)