Just out of curiosity, I was checking out the Morningstar fair values for my companies and surprisingly, they were all very close, minus AEO. So just for fun, here is a comparison of the intrinsic values between the companies I have written about on this blog between Morningstar and my fair value calculator. Small caps are not covered by Morningstar, so I have left them out.
(Morningstar fair value estimates as of Nov 19, 2008)
Morningstar vs Old School Value
ETN (published Nov 17, 2008)
Morningstar: $81 | OSV: $77
DPS (published Oct 28, 2008)
Morningstar: $28 | OSV:$25-$32
KSWS (published April 16, 2008)
Morningstar: $19 | OSV: $19.86
AEO (published March 11,2008)
Morningstar $22 | OSV: $37.37
So in the spirit of having some fun with stock valuation, it doesn’t seem like I need to bother with a premium Morningstar membership. I get pretty much the same quantitative assumptions with 100% control. You too start saving time and value stock quickly and automatically with the stock valuation calculator.
What is Old School Value?
Check out the live preview of AMZN, MSFT, BAC, AAPL and FB.